Uncle Sam Pays $40,000 for an $8 Knob: The Case For Military Right To Repair

Fight to Repair

SubscribeSign in

Uncle Sam Pays $40,000 for an $8 Knob: The Case For Military Right To Repair<br>A Senate hearing revealed a BlackHawk helicopter repair that costs 5,000 times more without a military right to repair. Also: Kindle owners push back as Amazon looks to brick older devices.

Fight to Repair Newsletter<br>May 18, 2026

Share

The push for the U.S. Military to be able to repair its own equipment has been a fixture of the U.S. Congress for almost a decade. As far back as 2019, Elle Ekman, a logistics officer in the US Marine Corps wrote a telling op-ed in the New York Times that described the huge obstacles that repair restrictions put on military members - and the jaw dropping costs that military repair monopolies impose on U.S. taxpayers.<br>More Right To Repair News:<br>Amazon Is About to Strand Older Kindles. Users Are Fighting Back

Your Car App Data May Have Just Become a Government Dragnet

Samsung Wants You to Upgrade, Not Repair

Aging Cars, Stalled EVs, and an Industry at a Crossroads

How Not to Become the Next Repair Horror Story

Nintendo’s Hardware Problem Is Becoming a Trust Problem

Still, those warnings and strong, bipartisan support in both Democratic and Republican led Congresses haven’t gotten the military right to repair over the line. It was just last December that Congress cut military right to repair language from the National Defense Authorization Act (NDAA) after lobbyists for defense contractors swarmed key lawmakers and convinced them to pull the repair provisions, which enjoyed bipartisan support and was championed by the Trump administration.

Congress Quietly Kills Right to Repair — Again<br>Fight to Repair Newsletter<br>December 15, 2025

Read full story

Despite repeated defeats, the tide behind the push for a military right to repair may be shifting as stories about the outrageous costs of the military repair monopoly become hard to ignore.<br>In a Senate hearing last week, Senator Elizabeth Warren (D MA) pressed Army leadership on military repair restrictions — and got a striking admission in response. The Secretary of the Army, Dan Driscoll, publicly called on Congress to authorize broader military right-to-repair authority, directly undercutting years of contractor arguments against reform.

To support his call for a military right to repair, Driscoll gave lawmakers a glimpse into the jaw-dropping costs to taxpayers of the U.S. Military’s inability to repair its own equipment.<br>Driscoll described a recurring problem with the military’s Blackhawk helicopters. Every month, four or more Blackhawks have a knob that breaks and needs to be replaced. The simple and most cost effective fix is for the military to just 3D print a replacement knob. That takes about an hour and costs around $8 per knob, Driscoll explained. However, the military’s contract with Lockheed Martin, which owns Sikorsky, the maker of Blackhawks, prohibits that, citing intellectual property (IP) rights. The result: Lockheed replaces the entire system attached to the broken knob at a cost of $40,000 each.<br>That means instead of replacing four knobs at an annual cost to taxpayers of roughly $380 and keeping BlackHawks in service, the military takes the copters out of service for extended periods so Lockheed Martin can replace much larger systems at an annual cost to taxpayers of around $2 million.<br>The exchange cuts to a problem that has simmered for years inside the Department of Defense: the military often buys highly advanced equipment but lacks the legal or technical ability to repair it independently. Contractors retain control over software, diagnostics, manuals, and proprietary parts, leaving the armed forces dependent on outside vendors for maintenance and readiness.<br>Secretary Driscoll told senators that U.S. soldiers have trouble accessing information needed to service and repair equipment in peacetime. In a war situation, however, not having access to the right to repair “could be the decisive point between us being successful somewhere 6,000 miles away in the Indo-Pacific or failing our mission if we cannot repair our equipment,” he said.<br>Military vendors are countering calls for a military right to repair by proposing “data as a service” for military equipment which would allow companies to meter DoD staff each time they access repair materials or data. That would likely only make the costs of equipment maintenance soar. As Warren pointed out: a defense contracting company already charges the Air Force $900 a page for upgrades to its maintenance manuals.<br>“Data as a service is just another attempt to gouge American taxpayers and put our service members at risk,” said Warren.

U.S. Defense Secretary calls for military to demand right to repair in contracts<br>Fight to Repair Newsletter<br>May 6, 2025

Read full story

Repair advocates have long argued that these restrictions don’t just raise costs — they weaken operational...