The Internet Needs More Cross-Pollinators · brennan.day

🌻 Welcome to brennan.day! I respect your decision to not use JavaScript. You can read here for more information about what functionality is disabled and why.

Skip to main content

White Cat with Bee by Harry Beard, 1876. Original image from Digital Commonwealth | Rawpixel (edited by the Author)

A few days ago, I launched a silly little web project the same way I have been doing for years. This one was different though, because people cared about it. Or at least, they cared about talking about it.

As I wrote a few days ago, I launched fanfiction.lol, a fork of the open-source repository Archive of Our Own. I decided to post about it on my poetry Tumblr, since the only reason I use Tumblr at all is to post my poetry. And I also blazed the post $10 for fun, which is the Tumblr version of advertising a post.

I've blazed posts in the past, trying to get people interested in my low-cost writing school or my values-driven webdev studio and they got a dozen or so notes. So I naïvely assumed that this project would have a similar fate.

It didn't, it got thousands of notes, and the site got nearly 200 sign-ups so quickly that I exceeded the free plan of my email provider SendGrid—who then blocked me from paying for a monthly plan because their KYC policy meant I needed to send them my identity.

No thanks. I switched to Resend which has a much more generous free tier of 3,000 emails a month. If I exceed that, then I'll freak out and figure out something else.

However, the amount of people talking about my project on Tumblr was far, far higher than the amount of people signing up. I received a lot of negative feedback at first:

"And do you have a legal fund to defend authors?"

"how is this actually different from ao3?"

"There already is a fanfiction website. Wtf"

"1. nothing will replace ao3 2. i feel like you could have at least changed the ui?? the layout is identical"

"Will you be able to host it for 5-10-15-20 years like ao3 does?"

"all of this is somehow weirder and sketchier than ao3 already is"

All because I started a website running in my basement on a 2012 CPU, wow!

It didn't take long for the tides to turn and for the vast majority of people to be kind and defend the site and my choice to start this project, though. The backlash to the backlash, for a thing that's just begun.

But the truth is, I understand the small amount of negative, hostile reaction I got.

When I first encountered SuperLove, before I even met the owner Melo, I could instantly tell it was a fork of AO3 and that, therefore, AO3 must be open-source. I've been a web developer for over a decade, and that kind of thing is intuitive to me.

But if you're someone who's grown up on the siloed corporate social media dystopian landscape of the Internet, and you've never encountered "forks" of projects or people creating websites for the sake of creativity and joy instead of for profit or clout, I can very much understand that upon first glance, it looks as though fanfiction.lol completely stole AO3's design and purpose.

Many people online are skeptical and paranoid of new websites and new ventures on the Internet because, for the past decade, the Internet has only been the oligarchy of Meta, Twitter, Alphabet, and Amazon. Anytime anybody has launched something new, it's been an NFT or crypto rugpull or AI-generated or some other horseshit.

Furthermore, these corporate oligarchs have instilled an idea of irrational platform loyalty and that the Internet is a zero-sum game. That you must dedicate yourself to a particular platform, with a particular subculture, and these other massive sites have their own subculture.

All of this is exactly why I've become such a loud, strong advocate for the IndieWeb. None of this is inherently true. The Internet is supposed to be hundreds of websites, created and owned by people and not massive for-profit companies. Take a look at NeoCities or NekoWeb or BearBlog if you want a few positive examples. There are hundreds, if not thousands of websites on each of these platforms.

And there are thousands more made from scratch just like mine, brennan.day.

All of this is to say we are in desperate need for cross-pollination on the Internet. About a month ago, I wrote a post where I neurotically worried about being taken seriously as a writer because the kind of writing I do on this blog felt out of place compared to many other writers on the IndieWeb. But then I got this brilliant reply from researcher Lori Ramey:

"or -- hear me out -- you are perfectly positioned to bring some of the intellectual intensity of the typical substack person into the cozier spaces where folks may find that they enjoy having something bigger to chew on once in a while.

In org theory (one of my research areas), a while back it was trendy in the research to talk about individuals in organizations who inhabit multiple spheres. Sometimes they were called...