The Only Game in Town | Not Even Wrong
Skip to content
Not Even Wrong
Home<br>Euclidean Twistor Unification
Frequently Asked Questions
← The Floer Jungle
The Only Game in Town
Posted on June 5, 2026 by woit
Warning: if you follow this blog, you’ve heard this many times before, so can move on to something more interesting now.
There’s a video conversation between Brian Greene and Lenny Susskind from last week here. At 44:02, Susskind has this to say:
One of the chief critics is a colleague of yours, I believe. And he is rather forcefully maintaining that string theory, until it can produce a success of the kind where you actually can produce a number and that number can be checked with experiment, that it doesn’t have any value.
The main reason for this post is just to reiterate that this is not what I think. The problem with string theory as a unified theory is not that it hasn’t made a tested prediction, but that it has made no predictions, of any kind. It’s very clear now that, as a theory of the real world it’s a speculative idea that just doesn’t work. As to whether it has "any value", you have to first define what "string theory" is. Under some definitions there are things of value, under others not.
Susskind goes on to accurately explain that any well-defined version of string theory (which he calls "String theory", capital S) definitely doesn’t correspond to the real world. But, he argues, maybe some new, unknown variant of String theory will work. According to him "It’s the only game in town" and "you have to see it through".
Brian later asks him "Is there anything that you could imagine happening in the field that would convince you that this is time to put it away?" "Finding it mathematically inconsistent" comes up, but he has already said that this is about an unknown new idea that would make things work. "I don’t know the answer to that" is then his answer: nothing would convince him. About other approaches doing better: "I think both you and I probably don’t put a lot of stock in there."
In case you haven’t seen this, something from a Kurt Vonnegut magazine piece:
A guy with the gambling sickness loses his shirt every night in a poker game. Somebody tells him that the game is crooked, rigged to send him to the poorhouse. And he says, haggardly, "I know, I know. But it’s the only game in town."
Share this:
Share on Mastodon (Opens in new window)<br>Mastodon
Share on Bluesky (Opens in new window)<br>Bluesky
This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.
← The Floer Jungle
Leave a Reply<br>Informed comments relevant to the posting are very welcome and strongly encouraged. Comments that just add noise and/or hostility are not. Off-topic comments better be interesting... In addition, remember that this is not a general physics discussion board, or a place for people to promote their favorite ideas about fundamental physics. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *<br>Comment *<br>Name *
Email *
Website
Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment.
you MUST enable javascript to be able to comment
Search for:
About<br>Peter Woit’s Home Page
Quantum Theory, Groups and Representations
Not Even Wrong: The Book
Reviews
Errata
Subscribe to Blog via Email
Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.
Email Address
Subscribe
Join 724 other subscribers
Recent Comments<br>End of Civilization News 17
Peter Woit, Mark Hillery, Peter Woit, Baptiste Le Bihan, Eric Lehman, Bobby W. [...]
Some Notes on AI 25
Will Orrick, Peter Woit, Mizan Khan, Symplectic Fish, Dmitri, Jim Holt [...]
This Week's Hype 4
Peter Woit, kitchin, Lars, clueless_postdoc
Wick Rotating Spinors and Twistors 6
Peter Woit, ohwilleke, Peter Woit, CB, Peter Woit, Tripitaka
Formalization of QFT? 27
A.J., John Baez, Peter Woit, Alex Gezerlis, cyd, Marko [...]
Categories
abc Conjecture (22)
Book Reviews (124)
BRST (13)
Euclidean Twistor Unification (21)
Experimental HEP News (155)
Fake Physics (8)
Favorite Old Posts (50)
Film Reviews (15)
Langlands (55)
Multiverse Mania (163)
Not Even Wrong: The Book (27)
Obituaries (36)
Quantum Mechanics (24)
Quantum Theory: The Book (7)
Strings 2XXX (28)
Swampland (20)
The Situation at Columbia (37)
This Week's Hype (151)
Uncategorized (1,326)
Wormhole Publicity Stunts (15)
Archives
Select Month June 2026 (3)<br>May 2026 (2)<br>April 2026 (1)<br>March 2026 (8)<br>February 2026 (6)<br>January 2026 (3)<br>December 2025 (4)<br>November 2025 (1)<br>October 2025 (3)<br>September 2025 (3)<br>August 2025 (4)<br>July 2025 (7)<br>June 2025 (7)<br>May 2025 (12)<br>April 2025 (11)<br>March 2025 (6)<br>February 2025 (3)<br>January 2025 (3)<br>December 2024 (4)<br>November 2024 (4)<br>October 2024 (3)<br>September 2024 (5)<br>August 2024 (6)<br>July 2024 (3)<br>June 2024 (4)<br>May 2024 (1)<br>April 2024 (5)<br>March 2024 (5)<br>February 2024 (6)<br>January 2024 (5)<br>December 2023 (2)<br>November 2023 (1)<br>October 2023...