Whipping the Democrats into Shape - by Sebastian

SubscribeSign in

Whipping the Democrats into Shape<br>The Second Installment in our series on Reforming Democratic Party Politics advocates for creating a real whip, and using it to refresh the party's willling.<br>Sebastian<br>Jun 18, 2026

Share

This is the second piece in a series on reforming Democratic internal party democracy. The previous installment covered reimaging the role of the Democrat’s House Leadership to become more confrontational and electorally-minded, including a significant proposal that would transform party democracy in the US by introducing a primary-style vote to select the party’s leader in the House or Senate. In this installment we turn to the party’s whipping system.

Democrats Should Treat the House of Representatives Like a House of Parliament and Campaign Like it.<br>Sebastian<br>Mar 18

Read full story

T he upcoming midterms are likely to be essential for the perpetuation of democracy in the United States. It is largely unspoken, but most understand though many won’t admit, that if the Democrats do not take control of most likely both the House and Senate in November then the chance for any sort of peaceful transfer of power in 2028 from Trump to a potential Democratic successor is vanishingly low.<br>The math is difficult, but doable. While redistricting wars have shifted the balance of power in the House from a near neutral state to now requiring at least a D+4 national environment to secure a majority, polling, special elections and state-wide elections over the last 18 months seem to strongly support the chance for Democrats to achieve at least that, if not significantly more than that in the national vote come November.

Competing Virginia Redistricting Referendum Advertisements, Source: Delcoan, [Wikimedia Commons]<br>Taking the Senate will be much more difficult, after a disasterous 2024 campaign left the Democrats down 47-53. They will need to pickup four seats to overcome vice-president JD Vance’s veto. Making matters worse, the current cycle didn’t leave Democrats with much in the way of battleground states to pickup. Before they worrying about picking anything up they need to defend seats in Georgia and Michigan, two states Trump won in 2024. Then their best shot at a pickup is Maine, an Obama-Clinton-Biden-Harris voting state that nevertheless has persistently supported Republican Susan Collins. While national polarisation and a surging populist insurgent seem to be swinging the state safer and safer into the Democrats hands, all this would represent just 1 pickup, 3 more are required, and they would all have to come from states that have voted for Trump 3 times.<br>Somehow though Democrats have seemingly put themselves in impressive positions to secure those pickups. Senate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer recruited some big guns to help them: Roy Cooper, the former two-term governor of North Carolina, Sherrod Brown, the longtime pro-labor Ohio Senator who was narrowly edged out in 2024, and Mary Peltola, the Alaska Congresswoman who managed 3 statewide wins for Alaska’s at-large house seat and had a shoe-in run for Governor had she chosen that.<br>With all this, plus promising candidates in Texas, Iowa and a surging left-aligned independent in Nebraska, the Senate had gone from the longest of shots, to maybe even a 50-50 flip with a favourable national environment for the left. But all of this forgets one thing - the Democrats are cursed with a Senator who doesn’t actually care much for the party. John Fetterman has made it effectively imperative that if Democrats want control of the Senate in 2026 they will need to reach 52 senate seats, converting another of their long-shot candidacies.<br>GreySidewalk is a young publication, help share us and our stories so we can grow our reader base!

Share

Fetterman, Rotating Villains, and the Failure of the D Whip

John Fetterman should be a familiar name to even the least engaged of US politics followers. In 2022 he ran an insurgent, Berniecrat-style candidacy in the ultimate swing state, Pennsylvania. Then he suffered a debilitating stroke and secured a commanding victory (in that order) only to then become the most Trump-aligned Democrat in the Senate.<br>Since 2024 he has sided with Republicans to help them defeat two government shutdowns (including the November shutdown where he was the only Democrat to vote to fund the government the entire time), has consistently voted in favour of funding ICE as much as Trump requests, was the only Democratic holdout on the War Powers Act even after it was certain to pass, and most famously has become the strongest voice in Democratic politics supporting Israel.

John Fetterman Meets with Israeli President Isaac Herzog, Source: Maayan Toaf, [Wikimedia Commons]<br>Many attribute this to his stroke, and while worth entertaining, the more likely story is that prior to his stroke he was at least much better at covering up his right-wing tendencies than he has since....