How to Live Without Options - and Why It's the Key to Happiness
WESTENBERG
SubscribeSign in
How to Live Without Options - and Why It's the Key to Happiness<br>It turns out closing doors is the key to happiness.
JA Westenberg<br>Jun 23, 2026
Share
Julius Caesar stood on the bank of a shallow river called the Rubicon.<br>It was 49 BC, and he was out of options.<br>The Senate, marshalled by his rival Pompey, had ordered him to surrender his command in Gaul and return to Rome as a private citizen, which in practice meant prosecution, ruin, and probably either exile or death. The river was the legal edge of Italy, and Roman law forbade any general from leading an army across it. To cross with his legion was treason - an open declaration of civil war he could never take back.<br>Plutarch and Suetonius both describe him stalling at the water’s edge, arguing with his officers, weighing the slaughter on one side against the humiliation on the other.<br>And then the moment came.<br>He quoted a line from Menander, a Greek playwright he loved, “let the die be cast,” and led the Thirteenth Legion across into Italy.<br>A few years later he was master of Rome - and by extension, the world.<br>We still quote that phrase, the die is cast. The crossing was the last moment Caesar could turn back; and he crossed to effectively destroy every alternative. Take away the irreversibility and the crossing is just a man fording a stream.<br>But Caesar was more than that.<br>Thousands of years later, “Keep your options open” has become the secular religion of the ambitious.<br>We give high-achieving young adults the same advice: optimize for flexibility. Take the dual degree. Start a side hustle, because it “leaves more doors open.” Date without labels, rent instead of buy, defer the permanent choice to keep tomorrow open.<br>We borrowed this instinct from finance - where pricing options under uncertainty has made countless literal fortunes. In markets, optionality has a precise, quantifiable, and strictly positive value: when the future is volatile, the ability to change your mind without penalty is the most valuable asset you can hold.<br>But apply that logic to personal life, to relationships, careers, community, and identity, and it backfires - every time. Psychological research keeps turning up a stubborn fact: human beings are measurably, predictably less happy with reversible decisions than with irreversible ones. We optimize for the escape hatch, but we keep finding out the escape hatch is the source of our misery.<br>I. Why Optionality Is Mathematically Correct
A financial option is the right - but not the obligation - to take a specific action in the future. A call option lets you buy an asset at a set price; a put option lets you sell.<br>An option works through its asymmetric payoff. Hold a call and the stock plummets: your loss is capped at the premium you paid, so you let the option expire. If it soars instead, your gain runs, in theory, without limit. You take all the upside of ownership without bearing its risks.<br>Real Options Theory
Economists carried the same logic beyond stock tickers and into the physical world. They built Real Options Theory in the 1970s and 80s to bring options pricing to tangible business decisions.<br>Imagine a mining company deciding whether to build a massive extraction facility. The price of copper swings wildly. Build the mine today, an irreversible commitment, and you risk bankruptcy if copper prices crash. Instead, the company buys the land rights and delays construction. It has bought a real option. If copper booms, it builds. If copper busts, it walks away, losing only the land cost.<br>Three principles follow from Real Options Theory:<br>Volatility increases the value of an option (in options pricing, this is Vega). The more chaotic and unpredictable the future, the more valuable the right to wait and see.
Irreversibility destroys option value. The moment the company pours the concrete, it exercises the option. The flexibility is gone, and the company now bears the full downside.
Time is an asset (this is Theta). The longer you have until you must decide, the more time there is for advantageous volatility to occur.
View human life as a chaotic, high-volatility system with incomplete information, and the financial mandate is clear: hoard options, delay every irreversible commitment, and guard your time and capital until the perfect risk-free opportunity arrives.<br>In a perfectly liquid market full of rational actors betting on exogenous events, this logic is flawless.<br>In his 2015 shareholder letter, Jeff Bezos sorted decisions into one-way doors and two-way doors. A one-way door is consequential and nearly irreversible, so you walk through it slowly, with deliberation. A two-way door is reversible, so you move fast and reopen it if you dislike what you find. He warned managers that big organizations start shoving every two-way door through the slow, agonized process meant for one-way doors. But we make the opposite mistake in our...