Len Sassaman — Satoshi Nakamoto Evidence — Byzantine Generals Problem | by Paul Marengo | MediumSitemapOpen in appSign up<br>Sign in

Medium Logo

Get app<br>Write

Search

Sign up<br>Sign in

Len Sassaman — Satoshi Nakamoto Evidence — Byzantine Generals Problem

Paul Marengo

6 min read·<br>Nov 15, 2023

Listen

Share

Press enter or click to view image in full size

This article is an addition to the theory posted here, that gives a very compelling series of evidence that Len Sassaman was the true identify of Satoshi Nakamoto. If you haven’t spent the time to do so I would recommend reading it throughly. Regardless if Len was or was not Satoshi he was a great man that tragically took his life due to suffering with depression amongst other health issues. All theories outlined in this article or the previous one are just that, theories. No one will likely ever be able to prove with 100% certainty. Here is a brief, incomplete, list of the evidence laid out in the linked article.<br>Len passed away a few months after Satoshi stopped contributing and posting on Bitcoin.<br>Len worked directly under David Chaum and with Hal Finney on various projects. Both pioneers in electronic cash systems.<br>Len used British English terms and spelling that Satoshi also used on forums.<br>Len was online and posting messages at a similar times as Satoshi, pointing to them being in similar timezones.<br>Len worked on distributed messaging systems that have many similarities to the Bitcoin protocol design. Most notably he was the maintainer of Mixmaster (a remailer that allowed you to send emails with more anonymity).<br>Len was very keen on solving the Byzantine Generals Problem, which would allow synchronization and consensus for distributed system (such as his Mixmaster remailer).<br>The last two points are the ones that will be of focus here. It is argued one of Bitcoin’s greatest feats and what makes the protocol possible is its ability to reach consensus on a distributed ledger or database without a third party. Effectively Satoshi expanded on Adam Back’s Hashcash system to create a chain of proof-of-work verified blocks to make this possible. Here you can read Satoshi describe how he solved it using proof-of-work in an email chain before the Bitcoin client was released.<br>If you look at the years 2005–2008 you will see Len has multiple academic papers researching possible solutions to the Byzantine Generals problem and its importance to mix-nets, like his own Mixmaster. The last paper on the subject titled The Byzantine Postman Problem was published in 2008, one year before Satoshi released the alpha version of the Bitcoin client in 2009. In this paper Len describes a way to solve the Byzantine Generals problem though a combination of hashing message blocks and verifying hash trees.<br>If Satoshi effectively proposed one solution to this problem in distributed systems it would make sense Len would be interested in such a solution and maybe even apply something similar to his own Mixmaster remailer. This can be checked as the Mixmaster repo is still up on source forge.<br>Press enter or click to view image in full size

The first interesting piece, Len’s last release and contribution to Mixmaster was in early 2008. It would make sense if Len was Satoshi he would have moved to working on Bitcoin in his free time as it was released one year later in Jan. 2009.<br>Similarities between remailers like Mixmaster and Bitcoin have previously been pointed out as even Adam Back suggested “Satoshi might have been a remailer developer.” In some ways Bitcoin is a combination of a remailer and Adam Back’s Hashcash to verify and bring consensus to the ledger as well as to issue new coins.<br>Remailers represent the “ground floor” of this house of ideas — the ability to exchange messages privately, without revealing our true identities. In this way we can engage in transactions, show credentials, and make deals, without government or corporate databases tracking our every move.<br>One Cypherpunk vision includes the ability to engage in transactions anonymously, using “digital cash”. … this is another area where anonymous mail is important.

-Hal Finney<br>Why did Len stop working on Mixmaster? He had plans to keep working on version 3.1, and further into the future as seen in Mixmaster’s “todo” file. A plausible theory is he found a way to solve the Byzantine Generals problem. A problem he has been pondering for years. A problem that was solved using a Hashcash proof-of-work system.<br>And in Len’s last release ever of Mixmaster in 2008 he has an item under todo that was not seen in previous releases.<br>Press enter or click to view image in full size

Whether this is a complete coincidence could be argued. Hashcash could be implemented to combat spam in a remailer and not to solve the Byzantine General problem or issue an e-cash currency. Or one could argue, in Len’s brilliant mind, while pondering how to implement Hashcash into his remailer he came up with a novel solution to the Byzantine...