Frankenstein Was a Warning, Not a Blueprint for AI – ideatrash
id*******@*******sh.net" />
Skip to content
by: Steven SausPosted on: April 27, 2026April 27, 2026
The necessity of a liberal arts background for STEM is made apparent nowhere moreso than AI research.
Because clearly they have not understood Mary Shelley’s Frankenstein.
You know, the one subtitled "The Modern Prometheus"?
It’s not "horror" in the modern sense. It’s horror in the sense of psychological dread, the unexamined consequences of one’s actions, and a creator’s responsibility toward the created.
Being conscious and aware is a mixed blessing at best. The joke in Rick and Morty’s "butter passing robot" is not that the self-aware robot is only there to pass butter.
It’s the last, less-quoted line from Rick: "Yeah, welcome to the club."
That line matters. It shows Rick’s default way of interacting with the world is sociopathic (something too many fans forget), but that Rick also realizes the joke is on everyone, including him.
None of us know what the purpose of life is. It’s existential dread, and it can be devastating.
The horror of Dr. Frankenstein’s hubris is the same horror we laugh at in Rick and Morty. We ignore it in order to function; that’s why we laugh at the robot’s "Oh my god" instead of Rick’s "Welcome to the club."
We talk about the utility, environmental costs, and copyright implications of LLMs. We absolutely should.
We do not talk about making sure that we are not cruel. (1)
Artificial consciousness is considered possible as an emergent property. There are researchers trying to create exactly that kind of strong AGI — artificial general intelligence — using current models of personality theory and psychology.
See also It Is Not Hypocrisy, It Is Projection.
This isn’t to argue that LLMs are conscious and self-aware.
But why would you strive to create an entity that is capable of having an existential crisis? That is sociopathic cruelty.
The reasons folks engage in this kind of development and research come down to "understanding our own consciousness" or "gaining knowledge".
We have ethics rules about human experimentation, both medical and psychological, developed in the 20th after abuses: Mengele, Tuskeegee, Zimbardo, Milgram, more. We still use data and information gathered in those experiments.
Those experiments gave us knowledge about the human condition (or gave the impression of doing so).
But they were also cruel.
So we stopped doing those experiments.
So when we find ourselves acting out a reverse Milgram experiment with LLMs, when we attempt to create something that could experience an existential crisis, the issue is not whether or not we succeed in doing so. The horror is not that it is created.
The horror is finding out that we are cruel enough to know exactly what we are doing… and we keep doing it anyway.
(1) We don’t guess if the anesthesia has taken effect before starting the surgery, why would we guess that we’re not being cruel? And before the vegans and vegetarians say it: Yes, I know.
Featured Image by Elisa from Pixabay
Search
Read Ideatrash
Subscribe to the Ideatrash RSS feed
Shop Ideatrash merch
Follow Steven Saus on Mastodon
Follow Steven Saus on Bluesky
Connect with Steven Saus on LinkedIn
View Steven Saus on GitHub
View Steven Saus on GitLab
View Steven Saus’s self-hosted Git repositories
View Steven S on Roll20
Book a game with Senor Wombat on StartPlaying
I don't have any trackers on here (even my link shortener is self-hosted and doesn't keep records), so comments (or coffees!) are quite welcomed.
I am tired of pretending they are not being cruel on purpose.
When The Reference List Has More Errors Than The Article: Autism Edition.
VibeOS – A Singular Expression Of Everything Awful About AI Hype
TV Really Helped Me: An Allegorical Tale
Possible Signs Of Poisoned Training Data In Generative AI Output Seen In The Wild
Running Everything On Manual: Responding to “But Everybody Feels That”
When Affirmation Turns Into Erasure, Neurodivergent Edition
Weaponizing Your Insecurity, aka Microcheating
Discussing What Used To Be Unthinkable
Sometimes It Ends Up Just Being Pretty Dots
githubGitHub
blueskyBluesky
mastodonMastodon
stevensaus.com