Say No to Online Age Verification
Say No to Online Age Verification
Skip to content
ESC
Members<br>Speech<br>Privacy<br>Culture<br>Tools<br>Antitrust
Recent
Privacy Ireland’s New Digital Wallet Turns MyGovID Into a National ID
Privacy The KIDS Act’s Next Stop Is the Senate. Make Your Voice Count.
Members The Memory Hole Above Beijing
Privacy Reddit to Require Login for Old Reddit, Curbing Anonymous Browsing
Once the checkpoint is built, the only question is what it guards next.
01
What Is Age Verification?
Age verification is a system that requires you to prove your age before accessing certain websites or online services. Instead of simply clicking “I am over 18,” you submit proof; a government-issued ID, a facial scan, a credit card, or biometric data, to a third-party company that confirms your age and grants you access.
It sounds straightforward and some people support it, usually because they’re not considering the implications. In reality, it means handing your most sensitive personal information to private companies every time you want to reach content the government has decided requires a check.
It started with adult websites. It’s spreading to social media, apps, and beyond.
02
Free Speech Chilled
Prove who you are before accessing a website, and you lose the freedom to think out loud, explore uncomfortable ideas, ask embarrassing questions, and read dissenting opinions, without a permanent record attached to your name.
Anonymous speech has always been the refuge of the vulnerable. Whistleblowers. Abuse survivors. Political dissidents. People questioning their government. History is full of ideas that only survived because the person who expressed them couldn’t be traced.
Tie your real-world identity to every click, every search, every post, and you self-censor. Not because you’re forced to. Because you know someone is watching. That chilling effect is silent, invisible, and total.
A free internet depends on the right to participate without identifying yourself. Strip that away, and every protection that depends on it goes with it.
And the scope never stays where it starts. Adult content today. Social media tomorrow. News, forums, search. Anywhere speech happens becomes a checkpoint requiring your papers.
03
Killing Privacy
Age verification has a privacy problem nobody in power wants to talk about.
When you upload your ID to access a website, you hand it to a third-party verification company you have never heard of, operating under rules you have never read, in a jurisdiction that may not be your own. That company stores your face, your name, your ID number, and a record of the site you were trying to reach. Then it becomes a target.
The breaches keep happening because the system demands they exist:
Discord’s age verification data was breached in 2025; real names, selfies, ID documents, home addresses, phone numbers, IP addresses and billing information all exposed.
A separate app leaked 13,000 ID photos and 59,000 selfies from an unsecured database.
An identity verification firm left login credentials exposed online for over a year.
In addition to collecting ID, some platforms have been surveilling users, building a profile on them and using algorithms to detect if they’re an adult or not. This type of system requires constant monitoring of a person’s every move on the platform and is incredibly privacy-invasive.
They are building the infrastructure for a surveillance state, and calling it child safety.
04
How We Got Here
It started with pornography. That was always going to be an easy sell.
January 2023
Louisiana becomes the first US state to mandate age verification for adult websites.
2023–2025
Half of all US states follow. The Kids Online Safety Act targets social media, messaging apps, and video games.
October 2023
UK passes Online Safety Act. Enforcement begins July 2025 with fines up to 10% of global revenue.
2024
Australia bans anyone under 16 from social media. Platforms face fines up to $32 million.
2025
Proposals extend to AI chatbots, VPN access, app stores, search engines. France blocks non-compliant sites at ISP level.
Now
Brazil, Canada, Spain, Italy, Singapore, and New Zealand all have laws passed or in progress.
The pattern is the same everywhere. Adult content first. Then social media. Then search engines, app stores, AI tools, messaging platforms. A single state law in Louisiana in 2023 has become a coordinated global framework, and the infrastructure being built to enforce it has no natural stopping point.
05
Kids Have Rights Too
When age verification comes up, the conversation almost always focuses on adults. What adults can access. What adults have to prove. What adults stand to lose.
Nobody talks about the kids.
Children and teenagers have First Amendment rights in the United States. Courts have recognized for decades that minors do not surrender their constitutional protections at the school gate or the login screen. Young people have...