Zombie ‘who owns Unix?’ lawsuit comes alive again
Jump to main content
Search
REG AD
OS PLatforms
Zombie ‘who owns Unix?’ lawsuit comes alive again
SCO's legal successor Xinuos asks legal brains to let it bite IBM over ancient license and copyright claims
Simon Sharwood
Simon<br>Sharwood
APAC Editor
Published<br>mon 6 Jul 2026 // 06:29 UTC
The ancient dispute over ownership of UNIX, and perhaps Linux too, has returned to court. Again.<br>As The Register has explained many, many, times since this matter first went to court in 2003, the roots of the case are the 1998 alliance between IBM and a company called the Santa Cruz Operation which sold a version of UNIX for x86 CPUs. Those two companies, plus Intel and Sequent, created “Project Monterey” – an effort to create a unified version of UNIX that could run on multiple processors.<br>By 2001, Project Monterey was close to delivering a unified UNIX, an achievement made possible by blending code from IBM and SCO.
REG AD
By then, a little project called “Linux” already ran on multiple processors. Big Blue decided Linux was the future and bailed from Project Monterey – then allegedly contributed some Monterey code to the open-source project and to its own AIX and Z operating systems. SCO felt it owned some of that code, so sued IBM.
REG AD
SCO and its successors struggled to survive, but interested parties kept the lawsuit alive because the chance to emerge as owner of parts of the Linux codebase, and IBM’s code, had the potential to turn into a colossal payday.
MORE CONTEXT
SCO v. IBM settlement deal is done, but zombie case shuffles on elsewhere
Yep, the 'Who owns Linux?' case is back from the dead
The Automattic vs WP Engine WordPress wars are getting really annoying
Unix is dead. Long live Unix!
The case and its successors ended in 2021, with a settlement that saw litigants agree to end the matter without IBM admitting fault.<br>But by then, SCO had sold its software to a biz called Xinuos that decided to fight on.<br>The Xinuos case has burbled along quietly since, and on June 22nd reached the milestone of a hearing.<br>The matter has become a little more modern, if only because this hearing was held online and the presiding judge appeared to unwittingly be on mute at one point. But the arguments otherwise seemed to revisit Project Monterey, debated the relevance of past litigation, contested who owned what, when they owned it, and how they could prove it. Xinuos argued IBM never had a license for SCO code. Big Blue argued that it did nothing wrong.<br>The core issue seems to be whether Xinuos even has the right to litigate the matter, or if some ancient legalese in the original agreements means the window for legal argument has long since expired.<br>The matter continues and appears likely to do so until either the heat death of the universe or the year of Linux on the desktop – whichever comes sooner. ®
legal<br>ibm<br>linux<br>os platforms<br>unix
REG AD
SYSTEMS
Microsoft flips Windows Backup to on by default unless you're in the EU
Everyone else must opt out manually if they don't fancy settings data shipped off-device
SECURITY
Enterprise AI still smarting from leaping before looking
Majority report AI-related security incidents or vulnerabilities
In a volatile world, a consistent sustainability policy is critical
SPONSORED FEATURE: ZTE unveils 2025 milestones
personal tech
DRAM prices are killing the cheap smartphone
Now eats 60% of a sub-$400 handset's bill of materials and it's only getting worse
columnists
Insert token to continue, says AI. Yeah, about that...
Barney Rubble points to bubble trouble
Cybercrime
Fake IT bods on Microsoft Teams coax workers into installing malware
Unit 42 says attackers are posing as helpdesk staff and persuading employees to hand over remote control before dropping EtherRAT trojan
MOST POPULAR
ai and ml
Even banks and hyperscalers are now sounding the alarm about the AI bubble
Security
Hackers shoveled snow for company, were rewarded with network admin access
os platforms
Former Microsoft engineer shrinks Notepad down to size
OFFBEAT
C programmers commit fresh crimes against readability
AI AND ML
New humanoid robots from China look like creepy pop star action figures – complete with slightly dodgy lip-synch
AI
AI and ML
Enterprise AI still smarting from leaping before looking
Majority report AI-related security incidents or vulnerabilities
Science
Boffins bet on quantum computers, AI supers to solve fusion fuel dilemma
Department of Energy, Cleveland Clinic, and IBM simulate a soup of molten salts and techno babble in pursuit of tritium
AI and ML
Software engineers can still rake in big bucks by working for fast-growing companies
AI's impact on tech business is complicated
software
Microsoft says the world is changing faster than it can keep up as it guts commercial, Xbox teams
Xbox chief says company can't afford to mistake longevity for inevitability
AI and ML
AMD’s Ryzen AI Halo makes...