Ex-NASA boss points out small flaw in Moon landing plan: No lander
Jump to main content
Search
REG AD
SCIENCE
Ex-NASA boss points out small flaw in Moon landing plan: No lander
Jim Bridenstine says Artemis 'extraordinarily complicated' compared to the days of Apollo and the Saturn V
Richard Speed
Richard<br>Speed
Published<br>wed 8 Jul 2026 // 13:50 UTC
Former NASA boss Jim Bridenstine has warned that the space agency's plan to land astronauts on the Moon risks becoming too complicated for its own good.<br>Bridenstine, who ran NASA during the first Trump administration and departed in 2021 before the Artemis I launch, told This Week In Space that the current lunar lander architecture looks worryingly elaborate compared with Apollo.<br>It is not Bridenstine's first intervention on the matter. In 2025, he questioned the architecture NASA selected – particularly SpaceX's Starship – to return astronauts to the Moon.
REG AD
REG AD
NASA has since reshuffled the Artemis plan. Artemis III is now set to be an Earth orbit test of lunar lander technologies, broadly in the style of Apollo 9, while the first crewed landing has slipped to Artemis IV, still optimistically penciled in for 2028. Bridenstine praised NASA Administrator Jared Isaacman for the shakeup.<br>The lander, however, continues to trouble him. Although complimentary about the Space Launch System and Orion capsule, which sent the Artemis II crew around the Moon, Bridenstine said: "What we don't have, and this is the challenge, we still don't have a lander. And without a lander, you can't land on the Moon. It's really that simple."<br>Blue Origin and SpaceX are working on landers, components of which are planned to be launched for a rendezvous with Artemis III. At present, Blue Origin plans to launch a vehicle that astronauts will be able to enter after docking. SpaceX is planning to test the docking mechanism, which will be mounted at the end of a Starship.<br>The mission profile for both vehicles is "extraordinarily complicated," Bridenstine said. SpaceX's lunar Starship, for example, will depend on multiple tanker launches and in-orbit propellant transfer before it can head for the Moon. Apollo, by contrast, launched the crew, command/service module, and lunar module on a single Saturn V rocket.<br>"The genius of Apollo was simplicity," he said. "They designed that thing to be as simple as you could possibly make it."
MORE CONTEXT
Ex-NASA chief gives Isaacman's Moon reboot a thumbs up, stays schtum on the awkward bits
SpaceX's Starship: Two down, Mons Huygens to climb
Ex-NASA chief: China likely to land humans on Moon before Uncle Sam does again
Bye-bye Bridenstine: Outgoing chief leaves NASA in good shape, though Boots on Moon by '24 goal looks doubtful
It was also not designed to last. By the final Apollo missions, the lunar module supported two astronauts on the surface for roughly three days, while the Artemis program anticipates far longer stays.<br>Bridenstine also noted that the proportion of the US federal budget allocated to Apollo was considerably larger than that of Artemis.<br>Even allowing for that budget gap, Bridenstine's concern is straightforward. At the moment, NASA has a rocket capable of transporting a crew to the Moon, but it does not have a way of getting a crew down to the surface – and the clock is ticking.
REG AD
"Whatever it takes to build a lander soonest is what we ought to be doing as a country," Bridenstine said. ®
nasa<br>moon<br>artemis<br>spacex<br>space<br>science
REG AD
SCIENCE
Ex-NASA boss points out small flaw in Moon landing plan: No lander
Jim Bridenstine says Artemis 'extraordinarily complicated' compared to the days of Apollo and the Saturn V
storage
Unexpected Windows bloat is due to bug, not by design
Mystery of the disappearing storage solved (for some)
Put all your data and AI to work and get it out of silos and lakehouses
PARTNER CONTENT: In the agentic era, intelligence has to be where the agents and data are acting, not separated from it.
Networks
Telstra outage: Failed emergency services calls, train chaos, payment systems down
Telco says issues all sorted, but transport networks expected to be disrupted well into Thursday
networks
Media Over QUIC can scale real-time streaming and carry the world's vids
The low latency of WebRTC, the scalability of DASH, and perhaps no need for CDNs
paas and iaas
Tech divorce from Walmart cost Brit retail giant Asda £1.22B
Project which included new SAP system saw delays and costs rise from an £800m estimate while causing financial disruptions
MOST POPULAR
ai and ml
Even banks and hyperscalers are now sounding the alarm about the AI bubble
Security
Hackers shoveled snow for company, were rewarded with network admin access
OFFBEAT
C programmers commit fresh crimes against readability
AI AND ML
New humanoid robots from China look like creepy pop star action figures – complete with slightly dodgy lip-synch
os platforms
Former Microsoft engineer shrinks Notepad down...