The Odyssey - Marginal REVOLUTION

Thank-you! You've been successfully added to the Marginal Revolution email subscription list.

Worth seeing, and I enjoyed it — but a few observations I haven’t seen elsewhere.

For all the praise of IMAX and 70mm’s supposed clarity, several scenes are out of focus on the actor. Pulling focus is harder with a large-format negative. The problem is compounded by Nolan’s fondness for darkness: too many scenes are dark enough to squander much of what the format offers. The sound was earth-shaking in the way we have come to expect from Nolan but there is no song.

The "woke casting" controversy is a non-issue — barely noticeable in practice. The film is obviously conservative in temperament. Helen gets some of the best lines, and Nolan’s slight disfigurement of her traditional arc is exactly right. The Circe scene is the best in the film.

Tyler is entirely wrong about Calypso. Odysseus’s seven years with her were among his most enjoyable. I have no doubt about this.

The deeper flaws are structural. Nolan loves to play with time, and the resulting flashbacks and memories ironically shortchange the odyssey itself — making the journey feel shorter and less arduous than it should. This is very much in the mode of Interstellar: a sequence of set-piece locations strung together. One planet/one monster/one scene–on to the next. But Odysseus as a character on an odyssey never quite coheres.

We are told repeatedly that Odysseus is smart but we shouldn’t need to be reminded. Odysseus is both beloved and resented by gods, a man whose men will follow him to the ends of the earth and then betray him but Mat Damon just doesn’t bring it. Things happen to him; he responds stoically. What we needed was the equivalent of Kirk defeating the Kobayashi Maru — a moment that makes the audience understand, viscerally, that this man bends the rules and contends with the gods by the sheer force of his wit and will. Of courses the Trojan horse is this but Nolan treats this as something of which Odysseus is ashamed and the other clever bits are downplayed. Damon never gets his Kobayashi Meru. The odyssey is a slog, rather than an adventure. Could have used a bit more Sinbad, a bit less Dark Knight. The dialogue, as Tyler noted, is lame.

Not Nolan’s best film but still better than most films and for scale, ambition, and grand themes well worth the 3-hour investment.

Marginal Revolution University

See Courses

Learn more about Mercatus Center Fellowships

Learn More

Subscribe via Email

Enter your email address to subscribe to updates.

Email Address

Subscribe

RSS Feed

Contact Us

Alex Tabarrok

Email Alex

Follow @atabarrok

Tyler Cowen

Email Tyler

Follow @tylercowen

Webmaster

Report an issue

Blogs We Like

Interesting People & Sites

Our Web Pages

Alex Tabarrok's Home Page

Alex's TED talk, how ideas trump crises

Conversations with Tyler

FDAReview.org

Tyler Cowen's Personal Web Page

Tyler's ethnic dining guide

Apply to Emergent Ventures

Books

Modern Principles of Economics

Tyler Cowen & Alexander Tabarrok