A story about Amara's law

tosh1 pts0 comments

Steven Sinofsky on X: "A story about Amara's law and why this is important with AI rn.

The first time I saw video transmitted over the internet was in 1994 with a tech called CU-SeeMe in a program called Global Schoolhouse. It was tiny 320x240 grey scale image at about 4fps. Audio was over a land https://t.co/jl7u4sDy0v" / X<br>Post

Log inSign up

Post

Steven Sinofsky

@stevesi

A story about Amara's law and why this is important with AI rn.

The first time I saw video transmitted over the internet was in 1994 with a tech called CU-SeeMe in a program called Global Schoolhouse. It was tiny 320x240 grey scale image at about 4fps. Audio was over a land line. Students at multiple locations could see each other and talk, and little else.

The next time was that same camera pointed at the stadium for the Lilyhammer Olympics. It did not replace NBC :-) I saw the closing ceremony as a stamp-sized still image of stadium lights, and little else.

Those were enough for many people to be convinced that internet video was the best big thing. CU-SeeMe became one of the earliest pure play internet video companies (and one of the rare users of UDP!)

It was also enough to convince the cable companies that internet video would never happen.

I demonstrated this technology to countless CEOs and luminaries from my office at Microsoft. There was a near perfect correlation between age or corporate seniority and doubt vs. enthusiasm, consistent with everything internet and most tech back then.

Today everyone uses internet video with resolution often higher than the tv they routinely use at home. And those cable companies that doubted internet connectivity and video distribute 4K tv over tcp/ip.

These things roughly followed Amara's law saying that people [enthusiastic supporters] often over estimate progress/impact in the short term and other people [incumbents] often under estimate progress/impact in the long term.

When people say AI is not ready or even more strongly AI will never do a certain, just keep in mind Amara's law and internet video. That is happening right now.

span:not(:empty)~span:not(:empty)]:before:content-['·'] [&>span:not(:empty)~span:not(:empty)]:before:px-1 [&>span:not(:empty)~span:not(:empty)]:before:shrink-0">12:34 AM · Jul 22, 20263.3KViews

101<br>505<br>28028<br>707

Read 1 reply

New to X?<br>Sign up now to get your own personalized timeline!<br>Sign up with GoogleSign up with AppleCreate account<br>By signing up, you agree to the Terms of Service and Privacy Policy, including Cookie Use.

Relevant people<br>Steven Sinofsky@stevesiFollow

Don't miss what's happening<br>People on X are the first to know.

Log inSign up

Trending now

internet video people span empty amara

Related Articles