Andrew Graham-Dixon on Vermeer, a Forgotten Sect, and Underrated Artists (Ep. 284) | Conversations with Tyler
All Episodes
LISTEN TO THE PODCAST
Subscribe on Google Podcasts
Subscribe on Apple Podcasts
July 22, 2026<br>Andrew Graham-Dixon on Vermeer, a Forgotten Sect, and Underrated Artists (Ep. 284)
Will the label beside every Vermeer have to change?
Subscribe
Apple
Stitcher
Spotify
YouTube
You may also like:
Andrew Graham-Dixon’s new book, Vermeer: A Life Lost and Found, rests on the conviction that you cannot understand what’s in a painting without knowing what its maker was thinking about. In Vermeer’s case, that context includes a forgotten liberal sect — the Remonstrants and Collegiants, Christians without a church who believed peace would come through reading and toleration rather than a returning Messiah. Recover that world and a woman alone in a sunlit room is a radical image in a Europe where half of Germany had just died in war. If he’s right, the label beside every Vermeer in every museum will one day have to change.
Tyler and Andrew discuss whether it was inevitable we’d rediscover Vermeer, how that vanishingly rare sect left its fingerprints all over his life, why the Met has misread its own Allegory of the Catholic Faith, whether Vermeer painted for money or pointedly refused to, where the Gardner’s stolen Concert might be, why Dutch music never blossomed as much as Dutch painting did, how the Church of England rivaled the Cultural Revolution in wiping out British art, whether you can still spot an English painting on sight, the love that saturates late Rembrandt and the mystery of his soaring print prices, the nail on the wall that proves two Vermeer paintings are a pair, why the French are to blame for George Stubbs’ lack of status, whether we can still love Malevich, why Andrews calls recent Richter "almost like printing money," why female artists and antique textiles remain absurdly cheap, why nobody builds beautiful neighborhoods any longer, and much more.
Watch the full conversation
Recorded April 7th, 2026.
TYLER COWEN: Hello, everyone, and welcome back to Conversations with Tyler. I’m very happy to be here today in person with Andrew Graham-Dixon. He is one of the world’s leading art historians, art critics, and he is prominent in the world of documentary. Andrew, welcome.
ANDREW GRAHAM-DIXON: It’s a great pleasure to be here, Tyler.
COWEN: Andrew has a new and fascinating book out among his many books. It’s called Vermeer: A Life Lost and Found. Let’s start with Vermeer. Why was Vermeer’s art forgotten for so long, until the middle of the 19th century? How could that happen? To us, it looks very accessible and beautiful, and obviously better than most of his contemporaries.
GRAHAM-DIXON: Well, this was part of the general mystery of Vermeer that I have tried to explain in the book. I don’t think it had previously been very well explained, but what has emerged quite clearly is that he painted basically all of these great paintings, the finest examples of his work, for one single family. They kept them very close. They left them to their daughter. She died young, left them to her husband. He died only in 1696, 20 years after Vermeer’s death, and only then did these paintings enter the world at large. Up until that time, they’d only been owned by one family.
I can’t think of another case of a great artist—I imagine if all Rembrandt’s pictures had been painted just for one man and his wife, we would never have heard of him probably.
COWEN: Where do they start being seen? What’s the first public unveiling of Vermeer as a great artist?
GRAHAM-DIXON: It would be in the mid-19th century when they were finally—the miracle is that these paintings were sold at auction. No one’s heard of Vermeer. As soon as they then get resold in the later 17th century, they’re being resold as if they were by other artists because Vermeer is not a name. He’s not like Gucci. Vermeer, if it gets sold, it gets sold as a Rembrandt or as a Gerard Douw, as even a Pieter de Hooch. His work is being sold under false currency, if you like.
What’s amazing is that it all survives, and it survives long enough for this wonderful guy called Théophile Thoré, who’s a French revolutionary exiled from France, goes to Belgium, a Frenchman’s idea of purgatory. But in Belgium, he discovers Vermeer and puts together the fact that all these paintings, which are masquerading as those by other artists, are actually by Vermeer. He says, “There is this painter called Vermeer. We never heard of him. Isn’t he incredible?” Within 50 years, 60 years, Marcel Proust writes his great novel, À la recherche du temps perdu, at the center of which he places a man, a character, a Swann, who is obsessed by Vermeer.
Proust makes it very clear that he regards the View of Delft as the most beautiful painting in the world. Vermeer is one of the greatest. From that moment onwards, Vermeer begins his ascent to become one of...