Replaceable but Employed: Automation and the Meaning of Work | NBER
Skip to main content
Search
Search
Replaceable but Employed: Automation and the Meaning of Work
Joshua S. Gans
Share
Bluesky
Threads
Link
Working Paper 35559
DOI 10.3386/w35559
Issue Date July 2026
Can automation harm workers without replacing them? We study jobs in which workers value both producing useful output and knowing that the output depends on their own contribution. A credible machine alternative can weaken that second source of meaning even when the firm retains the worker. Our model shows that this loss raises compensation when wages adjust fully; when they adjust only partly, workers bear some of the loss themselves. It can also make automation more likely. An external developer may profit by publicly demonstrating a machine before licensing it, because the demonstration lowers the value of the human alternative. This "meaning externality" can create demand for the machine and make profitable development socially harmful. Better technical quality and greater public salience have different effects: quality improves output, while salience alone weakens human work. Automation can, therefore, reduce the value of work before it eliminates jobs.
Acknowledgements and Disclosures
Thanks to Refine.ink, ChatGPT 5.6 and Claude Fable 5 for valuable research assistance. Thanks to the SSHRC for funding. Responsibility for all errors remains my own. The views expressed herein are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the views of the National Bureau of Economic Research.
Joshua S. Gans
Joshua Gans has drawn on the findings of his research for both compensated speaking engagements and consulting engagements. He has written the books Prediction Machines, Power & Prediction, and Innovation + Equality on the economics of AI for which he receives royalties. He is also chief economist of the Creative Destruction Lab, a University of Toronto-based program that helps seed stage companies, from which he receives compensation. He conducts consulting on anti-trust and intellectual property matters with an association with Keystone Strategy and his ownership of Core Economic Research Ltd. He also has equity and advisory relationships with a number of startup firms. Joshua is also a co-founder of All Day TA.
Citation and Citation Data
Copy Citation
Joshua S. Gans, "Replaceable but Employed: Automation and the Meaning of Work," NBER Working Paper 35559 (2026), https://doi.org/10.3386/w35559.
Copy to Clipboard
Download Citation
MARC
RIS
BibTeΧ
Download Citation Data
Related
Topics
Microeconomics
Welfare and Collective Choice
Behavioral Economics
Labor Economics
Labor Supply and Demand
Labor Compensation
Development and Growth
Innovation and R&D
Programs
Productivity, Innovation, and Entrepreneurship
More from the NBER
In addition to working papers, the NBER disseminates affiliates’ latest findings through a range of free periodicals — the NBER Reporter, the NBER Digest, the Bulletin on Health, and the Bulletin on Entrepreneurship — as well as online conference reports, video lectures, and interviews.
2025, 17th Annual Feldstein Lecture, N. Gregory Mankiw," The Fiscal Future"
Feldstein Lecture
Presenter:
N. Gregory Mankiw
N. Gregory Mankiw, Robert M. Beren Professor of Economics at Harvard University, presented the 2025 Martin Feldstein...
2025, Methods Lecture, Raj Chetty and Kosuke Imai, "Uncovering Causal Mechanisms: Mediation Analysis and Surrogate Indices"
Methods Lectures
Presenters:
Raj Chetty
& Kosuke Imai
SlidesBackground materials on mediationImai, Kosuke, Dustin Tingley, and Teppei Yamamoto. (2013). “Experimental Designs...
2025, International Trade and Macroeconomics, "Panel on The Future of the Global Economy"
Panel Discussion
Presenters:
Oleg Itskhoki,
Paul R. Krugman
& Linda Tesar
Supported by the Alfred P. Sloan Foundation grant #G-2023-19633, the Lynde and Harry Bradley Foundation grant #20251294...
Follow
© 2026 National Bureau of Economic Research. All Rights Reserved.