The Practice of Address: Loneliness and the Machines That Answer – New English Review
Skip to content
The Practice of Address: Loneliness and the Machines That Answer
Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...
by Christopher Carson (August 2026)
Woman at Window (Caspar David Friedrich, 1822)
There is a moment in Cast Away when the joke has already ceased to be a joke. The volleyball, at first no more than an accident of blood, paint, need, and improvisation, has acquired a face, a name, and a place in the castaway’s moral universe. Wilson is ridiculous only from the safe distance of society. On the island he holds a place no hallucination and no toy could hold, the frail remnant of a human order: someone to whom words may be offered, against whom fear may be steadied, through whom the castaway keeps alive the practice of address until the world of persons can be reached again.
Wilson’s loss is moving for just this reason. No one imagines that a volleyball has died, and yet the grief is not absurd. Something that had borne the weight of relation has been taken away, and with it the fragile form in which the castaway’s need for another person had been sheltered. The film understands, with the tact of genuine art, that loneliness runs deeper than the absence of company. It is the collapse of address, the condition in which the self has nowhere to go with itself and so begins to fall inward.
What follows is an attempt to name a familiar, half-hidden operation of the soul. When ordinary companionship is unavailable, humiliating, dangerous, forbidden, or too costly to pursue, human beings begin to search the remaining world for some object, creature, image, voice, or system capable of receiving the burden of social need. The surrogate need not be mistaken for a person in any literal sense. A widower does not suppose that the photograph answers him; a child does not believe, at every level of awareness, that the toy animal is alive; the castaway knows enough about Wilson’s rubber and paint. Yet knowledge of what a thing is does not exhaust what it may become when loneliness has pressed it into service. Human beings can inhabit more than one register of belief at once, and attachment often enters by a door that reason has left half open.
Those who treat artificial companionship chiefly as a problem of deception usually miss this more delicate drama. The lonely person is rarely simply fooled. More often he is doing something intricate and recognizably human: seeking a form through which his inward life can be externalized without rebuke, and preserving the habit of relation in circumstances that would otherwise extinguish it. If no one answers, the mind invents an addressee; if something answers, even faintly or mechanically, the invention becomes easier to sustain.
The mind’s search for company
Human beings do not meet the world as a bare inventory of things. We encounter it as promise, threat, invitation, rivalry, appeal. The child scolds the table against which he has struck his knee; the mourner speaks at a grave; the sailor curses the sea; the lover keeps an old letter whose paper holds nothing of the beloved, because memory needs a body if it is not to dissipate into air. These habits show consciousness to be social before it is analytical, and they show that even our dealings with objects are often touched by the longing for response. The impulse is no relic awaiting correction by enlightenment.
Psychology has given experimental form to this old truth, though the truth itself required no laboratory to be noticed. In the famous Heider-Simmel demonstration, viewers shown simple geometric figures moving around a box spontaneously supplied motives and plots: pursuit, fear, seduction, bullying, rescue.[1] Later work on anthropomorphism by Nicholas Epley, Adam Waytz, and John Cacioppo proposed that we attribute human qualities to nonhuman things most readily when the object resembles familiar agents, when we need to predict or control it, and when our need for social connection has been aroused.[2] Their further work made the crucial point still more plainly: loneliness can heighten the tendency to perceive humanlike qualities in nonhuman agents.[3]
The significance of this finding is easily flattened if we call it mere projection. Projection there may be, but projection is sometimes the form taken by petition. The isolated mind does something more exact than decorate the world with imaginary persons; it seeks a surface capable of bearing the pressure of address. The face seen in the clouds, the personality given to the family dog, the resentment felt toward the unreliable car, the gratitude toward a house that has sheltered several generations, all disclose a creature for whom relation forms part of the ordinary grammar of experience, never a mere ornament added to it.
This tendency has its uses. A being that failed to detect agency would not last long in a dangerous world, and...