Gmail might partially be to blame for receiving emails from other Sean Conners

Gmail might partially be to blame for me receiving emails from other Sean Conners - The Boston Diaries - Captain Napalm

The Boston Diaries

The ongoing saga of Sean Conner, who doesn't live in Boston, nor does he even like Boston, but yet named his weblog/journal "The Boston Diaries."

Go figure.

Tuesday, August 11, 2026

Gmail might partially be to blame for me receiving emails from other Sean Conners

I was reading the Lobsters thread about the article “A researcher bought noreply.net. Companies started sending him secrets” when I left a comment about my own struggles with receiving emails for other Sean Conners. That started a thread that swamped the comment section about other people who had similar stories, so it's nice to know that I'm not alone. Also, here's one of my favorite comments in that thread (for reasons that should be apparent):

I was about to say, "I know a guy with a whole blog series about that." But then I looked, and you were him.

Lobsters comment from Jason McBrayer

Heh.

But the thread as a whole left me with the idea that there's still a lot of people out there that barely understand email and aren't even sure what their own email even is. Sad.

I did get an email about my comment from Keong Lim, claiming it was mostly Google's fault for the confusion and linked to this fairly damning answer at Stack Exchange:

It is a lesson in human nature that so many experts simply recite Google's pat answer on this as if an assertion were identical to empirical reality. I am one of the early account holders with the firstname.lastname@gmail.com accounts. About three years ago, I began receiving email directed to firstnamelastname@gmail.com. By triangulating the information I was able to glean from their dry cleaners, car dealer, etc. I was finally able to contact these people (about 3,000 miles from me, BTW). The DO have the same account as me, minus the period. We were able to determine that only a portion of email "leaks" across accounts. Unfortunately, the fact that I had my account 10 years before they had theirs did not convince them to leave the account to me. Thus, I live with the occasional notice from the bank, school, etc. Because of this, I no longer use Gmail for anything important or confidential.

The most disturbing thing to me is Google's insistence that they could not have made a programming mistake when they clearly did. These folks are arrogant in their faux humility.

Why does Google not consider dot in usernames of Gmail addresses?

The “pat answer” is that Google is that it's cutting down on possible confusion over who receives firstname.lastname@gmail.com and firstnamelastname@gmail.com, but it seems that the “pat answer” is a somewhat later change to Gmail to ignore periods in the local part (the part before the “@”) of the email address. I think Gmail is leaning heavily upon this portion of “RFC-5321: Simple Mail Transfer Protocol” to justify this:

2.3.11. Mailbox and Address

As used in this specification, an "address" is a character string that identifies a user to whom mail will be sent or a location into which mail will be deposited. … Consequently, and due to a long history of problems when intermediate hosts have attempted to optimize transport by modifying them, the local-part MUST be interpreted and assigned semantics only by the host specified in the domain part of the address.

(emphasis added)

I know I signed up early enough to Gmail to get sean.conner@gmail.com and at that time, seanconner@gmail.com might have been considered a different email address. After the change, it appears that Gmail might get confused sometimes and mess up some legacy addresses at times.

While reading all that, I did go down a small rabbit hole with what characters are actually allowed in an email address. It's unclear if anything but ASCII is allowed, but there are surprisingly little in ASCII that isn't allowed. Out of the 95 defined graphic characacters (which I'm including the space character), the following are not allowed:

ASCII characters not allowed in an email address

character name

Space " Quotation Mark ( Left Parenthesis ) Right Parenthesis , Comma : Colon ; Semicolon Less-than Sign > Greater-than sign @ Commercial At [ Left Square Bracket \ Reversed Solidus ] Right Square Bracket

Technically, they could be used in an email address if they're escaped, but it's discouraged heavily.

Current

First

Last

Top

Home

About

Gmail might partially be to blame for receiving emails from other Sean Conners

Related Articles

(no title)

Scientists reverse brain aging, with a nasal spray

NHS apologises and admits Palantir have access to identifiable patient data

AI has torched the market for junior programmers

Al Vigier: Canada's AI strategy shouldn't include secret Palantir bills