Apple: DOJ’s latest challenge in antitrust case ‘fails at every level’ - 9to5Mac

Skip to main content

Toggle social menu

Toggle dark mode

Search for:

Submit

Toggle search form

Toggle dark mode

AAPL Company

Apple: DOJ’s latest challenge in antitrust case ‘fails at every level’

Marcus Mendes | Aug 17 2026 - 5:56 pm PT

5 Comments

Apple is pushing back against the Department of Justice’s bid to overturn a court decision allowing the company to seek documents from more than a dozen federal agencies. Here are the details.

A bit of background

A few weeks ago, Apple secured the right to seek documents from 14 US agencies as part of its defense against the antitrust case the Department of Justice brought against the company in March 2024.

That includes the following agencies and departments:

Central Intelligence Agency (CIA)

Department of Commerce

Department of Homeland Security

Department of Defense

Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI)

Federal Trade Commission (FTC)

General Services Administration

Department of Labor

National Aeronautics and Space Administration (NASA)

National Security Agency (NSA)

Office of the Director of National Intelligence

Office of Management and Budget

Office of Personnel Management

Department of State

Apple’s premise is that if it can show the federal government chose its products for their privacy features, that evidence could support its argument that the practices challenged by the DOJ have legitimate justifications rather than being anticompetitive.

Following Apple’s victory in this dispute, the DOJ filed a motion asking retired federal judge Jose Linares, who is serving as a special discovery master in the case, to reconsider his decision.

In complex cases involving extensive discovery, courts sometimes appoint a special master to resolve narrower disputes and ease the workload of the judge overseeing the broader case. Special masters can be retired judges, practicing attorneys, or other experts with relevant experience.

In its motion, the DOJ asks the court to reverse Apple’s discovery win, arguing that Judge Linares applied the wrong legal standard by treating the agencies as parties to the case, rather than non-parties entitled to greater protection from discovery.

The DOJ also argues that Apple’s requests would impose an undue burden on the agencies, relying on 13 newly submitted declarations, and that the documents have limited relevance because federal agencies are not “ordinary consumers.”

’The Motion fails at every level’

Apple’s response to the DOJ’s motion has now been made public, and the company minces no words in refuting every argument made by the DOJ in its bid to reverse the decision.

Apple cites several previous cases to argue that “the special master correctly applied the legal standard for party discovery from federal agencies,” and then picks apart the DOJ’s arguments of undue burden and relevance.

In its conclusion, Apple says:

The Motion fails at every level. Its legal arguments are impermissible re-litigation; its new evidence" was always available and cannot properly be considered; and even on the merits, the declarations do not establish undue burden. Apple respectfully requests that the Motion be denied.

According to the timeline set by Judge Linares on August 4, no further briefing will be permitted, and it is now up to him to either uphold his original discovery order or grant the DOJ’s request to reconsider it.

You can read Apple’s response to the DOJ’s motion below:

gov.uscourts.njd.544402.493.0Download

Worth checking out on Amazon

Geoffrey Cain – ‘Steve Jobs in Exile’

David Pogue – ’Apple: The First 50 Years’

MacBook Neo

Logitech MX Master 4

AirPods Pro 3

AirTag (2nd Generation) – 4 Pack

Apple Watch Series 11

Wireless CarPlay adapter

FTC: We use income earning auto affiliate links. More.

You’re reading 9to5Mac — experts who break news about Apple and its surrounding ecosystem, day after day. Be sure to check out our homepage for all the latest news, and follow 9to5Mac on Twitter, Facebook, and LinkedIn to stay in the loop. Don’t know where to start? Check out our exclusive stories, reviews, how-tos, and subscribe to our YouTube channel

Featured

from 9to5Mac<br>9to5Mac Logo

Here’s what’s new with iOS and macOS 27 beta 6

Zac Hall

Aug 17 2026

AirPods with cameras get their clearest leak yet

Marcus Mendes

Aug 17 2026

Apple releases iOS 26.6.1 for iPhone, here’s what’s new

Ryan Christoffel

Aug 17 2026

Two camera features may be unique to the iPhone 18 Pro Max, suggests leaker

Ben Lovejoy

Aug 18 2026

Podcast

Check out 9to5Mac on YouTube for more Apple news:

Comments

Expand<br>Close<br>comments

Expand<br>Close<br>comments

Guides

AAPL Company

Breaking news from Cupertino. We’ll give you t…

Author

Marcus Mendes

https://www.threads.com/mvcmendes

Marcus Mendes is a Brazilian tech podcaster and journalist who has been closely following Apple since the mid-2000s.

He began covering Apple news in...